Who do you believe has more value coming into 07, Jhonny Peralta or Andy Marte? Peralta has hit better and plays a more difficult position, but according to the front office, plays it poorly. Marte had a tough year with the bat last year (and still has yet to top .285 any year or any level, something Peralta already did in the majors), but his defense is supposedly good at 3B.
I'm interested in peoples opinions, and the reasons given. For example "If peralta played 3B he'd be better defensively than Marte" (I have no idea if this statement is true or not).
Who is more valuable?
Jhonny Peralta (48 votes)
Andy Marte (51 votes)
99 total votes