Posted this a couple of weeks ago. With a few more weeks of data, here would be my selections for the 31 man roster (starters in bold):
C - Vic, Posada, Johjima
1B- Ortiz, Teixeira, Morneau
2B- Polanco, Upton
3B- ARod, Lowell
SS- Guillen, Jeter
OF- Mags, Vlad, Hunter, Ichiro, Granderson, Grady, Rios
P - Haren, Sabathia, Beckett, Verlander, J Santana, Escobar, Meche, Bedard, FRod, Putz, Jenks, Papelbon.
Teixeira, Bedard, Rios, Haren, Upton, Meche, and Jenks would be their team's only rep.
My vote-in Top 5 would be: Sheffield DET-DH, Youkilis 1B-Bos, Roberts 2B-BAL, C Pena 1B-TB, Kotchman 1B-ANH
Apologies to Glaus 3B-TOR, O Cabrera SS-ANH, B Harris SS-TB, Jhonny, Cust OAK-OF, Swisher OF-OAK, AReyes TB-CL, Nathan CL-MIN, Lackey ANH-SP, and Buerhle SP-CHW.
However, the fan voting would adjust that by Pudge starting at catcher (bye Johjima).