Being a veteran elementary school teacher I prefer letter grades to the invogue rubrics. Here are a some; please feel free to rate all the Indian's players.
Martinez A+
Sabathia A+
Carmona A
Peralta A
Nixon D
Sizemore B+
Michaels B
Barfield C+
Betancourt A+
Borowski A+
Lee B-
Delluci D
Shoppach A
Blake B+
Garko B