Fausto Carmona?

I know it won't happen, but should it happen? If we didn't know both CC's and Fausto's histories - 100 game winner vs. 1-10 last year - which pitcher would we think is more dominant headed into the playoffs? Obviously, they're both great. But! On 3 days rest (potentially), would you rather have a tired CC or a tired (sinkerballer!) Fausto?

Just a thought. Discuss.