Maybe a Dumb Idea
So I'm prefacing this by saying that I'm sitting in Copyright class and just got called on. I was pretending to look through my notes to remember what Baker v. Selden is about, but my computer screen was actually Swerb's Blurbs. Halfway through faking my way through a semi-intelligible answer (I'm a 3L who had 8 years of Jesuit education; if there's anything I can do, it's BS like a champion), this thought popped into my head as to the Indians infield. That's a long way to say this may be a terrible idea, so tell me if it is.
Asdrubal is clearly a better defensive SS than Jhonny, or at least that seems to be the near-universal presumption. Jhonny may or may not be able to play third at a high enough level to justify sticking him there, though that creates the problem of what to do with Andy Marte (Marte may suck it up this spring and make that a non-issue, but I'd at least like to give him the chance to suck). Why can't we just switch Astro Cab and Jhonny until we find out what we have at third?
I played enough baseball to reasonably think that 2d is an easier position than short; is it less important? I don't know enough about defensive statistics to know the answer to that. And I'm not assuming that just because Jhonny is an adequate to above-average shortstop he'll automatically be as good at 2d. But I've never seen the discussion and the idea just popped into my head.
0 recs |
52
comments
Comments
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
My short answer is that I have no idea.
My slightly longer one is that I remember when Phillips/Peralta looked like the MI of the future, even casual fans were wondering why it was Phillips 2B, Peralta SS when they each seemed to be better suited for the opposite positions.
by Voltaire on Jan 24, 2008 3:51 PM EST 0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by CU Adam on Jan 24, 2008 4:06 PM EST 0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by Voltaire on
Jan 24, 2008 4:09 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by fleerdon on Jan 24, 2008 4:16 PM EST 0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by stuart dean on Jan 24, 2008 5:08 PM EST 0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
A) Asdrubal is for real, I think he is, but he is far from a sure thing.
B) Can Josh Barfield bounce back? It's certainly plausible, although I'm not overly confident.
C) Will Andy Marte break through?
If A and B happen, but C doesn't, then we can move Jhonny to 3rd in the offseason.
If A and C happen, then you decide if you think Jhonny can handle second.
If only B and/or C happen, you leave him at short.
by ClarkM on Jan 24, 2008 5:22 PM EST 0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by Jay on Jan 24, 2008 5:32 PM EST 0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by Thommy on
Jan 25, 2008 12:20 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
Asdrubal at short and a tolerable Jhonny at 2nd with Carroll spelling him sounds like a good defense for groundballers.
by nickjs21 on Jan 24, 2008 5:35 PM EST 0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by Brick. on Jan 24, 2008 5:53 PM EST 0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
I'm not going to chime in on your idea, because, in honor of that case, I intend to post a separate diary proposing that the Indians "switch Jhonny and Astro Cab" (as opposed to your suggestion that they switch "Astro Cab and Jhonny").
My only question for you is that as a second semester 3L, what the hell were you doing in class in the first place?
by Harry Doyle on Jan 24, 2008 6:01 PM EST 0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
But not as much as profs who decide to take attendance for the first time in their careers after I've already set up my schedule based on easy classes.
by CU Adam on
Jan 24, 2008 9:20 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by Denver Tribe Fan on
Jan 25, 2008 12:36 AM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by CU Adam on
Jan 25, 2008 1:18 AM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by Denver Tribe Fan on
Jan 25, 2008 9:12 AM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
18 years ago - before the inter-nets were invented, a friend of mine and I spent the better part of our Decedents, Estates and Trusts class matching up each NFL team with their stadium. We got all but one before class was over - at the time Jack Murphy Stadium in San Diego.
by Harry Doyle on
Jan 25, 2008 12:34 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by fleerdon on
Jan 25, 2008 2:48 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by Brick. on
Jan 25, 2008 3:06 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
I for one went to class as little as possible by my third year. Since the school was in Newark, I had little incentive to go there anyway. Still I had no problems passing the bar.
(Well, THAT one anyway.)
by Harry Doyle on
Jan 25, 2008 5:39 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by fleerdon on
Jan 25, 2008 7:17 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by Denver Tribe Fan on
Jan 25, 2008 7:52 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by Harry Doyle on
Jan 26, 2008 12:28 AM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by fwembt on
Jan 26, 2008 7:06 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
I hate that the bar will limit my baseball watching this July.
by DaytonDogg on
Jan 26, 2008 11:49 AM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
Scrap the All-Star game. Decide WS home-field advantage by interleague play. Lop a few games off the regular season. Make the All-Star break a full week long. Rather than have two all-league teams, put together the best team from every conference. Have them play each other in best of 3 series: East vs. Central, East vs. West, West vs. Central. At stake is home field advantage in ALDS and ALCS, with the wild card always playing away.
Feel free to just devolve into who makes the All-AL Central Team. That's how I got into this, anyway.
by fleerdon on Jan 24, 2008 6:02 PM EST 0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by fleerdon on
Jan 24, 2008 6:04 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
Pitchers are Santana, CC, Verlander, Willis, Carmona, Nathan, Jenks, etc.
Doesnt sound fun...toughest division in baseball...
by Tribe Alive on
Jan 24, 2008 6:58 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
For Peralta he would actually become a better fielder almost instantly by moving to 3rd or 2nd base. His lack of range certainly would be come less of a problem at 3rd and given he has played the position that would that make his transition much easier. He would be a better second basemen but only slightly and his transition wouldn't be as smooth and it definitely would cut our double play possibility at least for a few months until the pivot became more natural.
by E5 on Jan 24, 2008 6:03 PM EST 0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by Jay on
Jan 24, 2008 6:25 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
Jeter S_c_s.
by E5 on
Jan 24, 2008 6:28 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
Reminds me of Jay's classic 'genuflecting to the cult of Jeter' rant from way, way back.
by jhon on
Jan 24, 2008 7:32 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by Jay on
Jan 24, 2008 7:36 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
I believe A-Rod's real problems started not in Texas but in New York. He was a leader in Texas -- maybe not beloved or revered, but not disliked or disrespected either.
It was only after he went to New York and essentially prostrated himself to the Cult of Jeter -- moving to 3B and reportedly "following Jeter around like a puppy dog" -- that everyone lost respect for him.
By the time he's done, A-Rod may well have had the greatest career in the history of the game. He should have embraced that role and played that part on any team he was on. He should not have "needed" to play for the Yankees, and he certainly shouldn't have put himself in the position of needing Jeter's approval.
All of the Yankees, even the greatest ones, know that the institution of their team is bigger than any one of them. But the Yankees are not bigger than A-Rod, and they expect A-Rod to genuflect all the time. But that's not the worst part. The worst part is, A-Rod has been genuflecting.
Yes, I think he needs to get out of there.
by nickjs21 on
Jan 24, 2008 7:45 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by jhon on
Jan 24, 2008 7:52 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by jhon on
Jan 24, 2008 7:54 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by jhon on
Jan 24, 2008 9:04 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by Jay on
Jan 24, 2008 11:20 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by supermarioelia on
Jan 24, 2008 8:19 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by hans on
Jan 24, 2008 9:58 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
E5 I hope you prove what I just posted wrong, because I would really be interested in the source material, but I'm guessing you probably don't post back.
by hans on
Jan 24, 2008 10:02 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by fwembt on
Jan 24, 2008 10:57 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by mauichuck on
Jan 25, 2008 9:18 AM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
As in how Hart never packaged guys like Brian Giles, Richie Sexson, Damien Jackson, Dann Graves, Jeromey Burnitz, Brian Anderson, Alex Ramriez, Enrique Wilson, Shuey, etc. to put us over the top.
Instead, he frittered them away or they flamed out, one by one.
Giles for Ricardo Rincon
Sexson, etc. for Bere, Woodard and Wickman
Burnitz for Seitzer
Wilson and Alex Ramirez for Will Cordero
Damien Jackson/Danny Graves/Winchester for Smiley and Branson
Brian Anderson left unprotected in 1997 expansion draft.
Shuey (The Filthy One) could never quite stay healthy.
---
Look, I'm not second guessing...giving up a gaggle of talent for that one player is a risky proposition. And there was no way of knowing who was going to pan out and who wasn't. Plus, not all of these players were so highly touted.
But I will say that from 1996-2000 I remember these guys being mentioned in July and in December and the trigger was never pulled.
by jonnykilbane on Jan 24, 2008 7:59 PM EST 0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
Thanks for reminding me about Al-Ram and Enrique for Wil Cordero ... I should bring that up whenever someone says we should trade more of our prospect depth. Wil Cordero, past his mediocre prime, that's what's pretty much what's available for a couple of B- prospects.
by Jay on
Jan 24, 2008 11:24 PM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
However, Sexson had a pretty nifty run for 5 or 6 years when he gave MIL and SEA something in the neighborhood of .270 / 40 / 120 / .900.
And in Giles' first 4 or 5 years he was somewhere around .310 / 40 / 110 / .1000
So, not all of these guys were stiffs.
I guess what I'm saying, looking back on 96-99 is that when you had as much money as the Tribe did, had the farm system the Tribe did, and were close as the Tribe was, sometimes you have to pull the trigger before you know that you prospects (like those above) are stiffs.
Put another way, look what the Yankees gave up for Clemens the first time around:
Graham Lloyd, an above-average reliever.
David Wells, a clearly on the downside starter.
And Homer Bush, who ended up being worth little more than a bag of balls.
So, I guess I'm saying that Hart never seemed to be willing to part with the Homer Bushes, until they became much less valuable.
And, believe me, I understand that the Tribe of today couldn't operate this way...but the Tribe of yesteryear had every reason to make a big gamble or two. And they never did.
by jonnykilbane on
Jan 25, 2008 12:28 AM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by Bogalusa Bomber on
Jan 25, 2008 6:12 AM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
I dunno - the Marlins have had some success with that approach. In fact they've won damn near as many World Series in their 14 years of existence as the Tribe has in over a 100 years. All depends on who's runnin' the show and a little luck.
by mauichuck on
Jan 25, 2008 9:31 AM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
And a lot of luck too.
by Bogalusa Bomber on
Jan 26, 2008 1:36 AM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
As for the Clemens deal, Homer Bush was basically a throw-in. You want to dismiss David Wells as "clearly on the downside," but just a few weeks earlier, he was 3rd in the Cy Young voting. That trade was basically upgrading one veteran pitcher to another, so they threw in a good reliever and a decent prospect. I don't think it represents any kind of example of how to use depth prospects to get meaningful and immediate upgrades.
by Jay on
Jan 25, 2008 8:11 AM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
by Bogalusa Bomber on
Jan 25, 2008 9:25 AM EST
up
0 recs
Re: Maybe a Dumb Idea
I never understood it, and just had to conclude that the decision had been made, for whatever reason, that Jhonny just can't play 2B, and that was that. No use even trying. I don't think he'll ever even practice the position in Cleveland, ever.
by mcrose on Jan 24, 2008 8:18 PM EST 0 recs








