June Prospect Grades

The season is far enough along to look at how some of our prospects have done so far.  This list is focused largely on the guys that matter.  Each player is valuated independently and the grade represents how they’ve performed relative to what expectations/hopes for them were at the beginning of the season.  Feel free to disagree or add your own.




Jordan Brown: (.272/.329/.384)

Hope: Add power to his superior AVG/OBP skills

Reality: Has maintained a decent average until late, but BB-rate has declined and has not shown any improvements in power.

Grade: C-


Josh Barfield: (.264/.305/.398)

Hope: Learn the value of a walk, improve defense

Reality: I haven’t heard any reports on his defense in Buffalo, but his BB%, while improving, is still not where it needs to be. He hasn’t been the total trainwreck he was last season, though, and I think there’s still reason for hope.

Grade: C+


Michael Aubrey: (.301/.345/.449 minors)

Hope: Stay healthy, hit line drives, show he can still play the field

Reality: His offense has hardly been overwhelming, but he’s done most of the rest well enough to earn more than a week in Cleveland.

Grade: B


Jeremy Sowers: (60.2IP, 43K, 17BB, 2.08)

Hope: Re-establish himself as a middle of the rotation major league starter.  Keep BBs and HRs down, bring K-rate over 6/IP

Reality: He’s done these things for the most part.  Sowers margin of error remains small, so it would be nice to see his walks come down even further.  It’d also be nice to see some of his Ks translate to the big league level.

Grade: A-


Adam Miller: (28.2IP, 20K, 12BB, 1.88)

Hope: Stay healthy

Reality: Another injury

Grade: D


Buffalo/Akron Relievers: (Jeff Stevens, Reid Santos, Ed Mujica, Randy Newsom, et al.)

Reality: The bigger names of this group have had pretty disappointing early seasons.  Some of the older guys have done better.  The shuttle between Buffalo and Cleveland is in full effect.

Grade: C-





Chris Gimenez: (.307/.473/.496)

Hope: Keep hitting enough to justify pushing him forward.  Find a place for him to play defensively.

Reality: He’s the Indians best minor league hitter right now and he’s getting a lot more work at C, increasing his potential value.  It’d be nice to see some HRs.

Grade: A


Wes Hodges: (.300/.359/.468)

Hope: Stay healthy, add power

Reality: His numbers are almost identical to last season’s (at Kinston) thus far.  It’d be nice to see him start forcing his projections upwards a bit.

Grade: B


Josh Rodriguez: (.264/.361/.351)

Hope: Cut down on Ks, maintain BBs and power, improve defense

Reality: Of those hopes, all he has effective done is maintain his BBs.  His 13 Es lead the team.  He’s developing a rep as one of the system’s streakiest hitters with really good hot stretches, and really terrible bad stretches.  More bad than good so far this season.

Grade: D


Matt Whitney: (.239/.327/.371)

Hope: Maintain the power from ’07 and force his way to Buffalo

Reality: After an excellent first couple of weeks it has been all downhill.  When the Buffalo (and Cleveland) call-up came, it was Aubrey and not Whitney who took advantage of the opportunity. 

Grade: D


Trevor Crowe: (.200/.333/.307)

Hope: Stay healthy, get on base a lot, steal a lot of bases

Reality: No, not really, no. (although for the eternally hopeful, June’s treated him well so far)

Grade: F


David Huff: (65.2IP, 62K, 14BB, 1.92)

Hope: Stay healthy and show superiority to AA-hitters

Reality: He’s done just that and with his promotion to Buffalo this week, is entering the 2009 starting rotation radar.

Grade: A


Chuck Lofgren: (52IP, 43K, 35BB, 5.54)

Hope: Get his K-rate back up to 1/IP and improve his BB-rate

Reality: Control has actually gotten considerably worse.  Aside from his two starts the first week of May, he’s been terrible.

Grade: D-





Nicholas Weglarz: (.270/.423/.416)

Hope: Continue to pile up the walks and hit many many monster HRs

Reality: Lots of walks, not a lot of power

Grade: B- (victim of high expectations)


Beau Mills: (.255/.358/.421)

Hope: Show improved plate discipline (5:2 K:BB in 2007) and legitimate power

Reality: Place discipline has improved (4:3 K:BB), but power has been mainly in the form of doubles so far (17, .166 ISO)

Grade: B


Jared Goedert: (.269/.343/.385)

Hope: Stick in the middle infield, spray line drives and show reasonable power

Reality: Goedert’s power has dropped off considerably this year.  Needs a strong 2nd half to retain prospect status.

Grade: C-


John Drennen: (.278/.366/.317)

Hope: Cut down on Ks, put together a solid all-around season and establish himself as a legit prospect

Reality: He’s cut down the Ks and improved his BB-rate, but while completely losing his power.  Hopefully just a stepping-stone in his development.

Grade: C


Carlos Rivera: (.274/.314/.363)

Hope: Defense remains viable at SS, continues to add a little power

Reality: He’s still at SS (although his 10 Es do lead the team), but his BB-rate is half what it was last year, and his power has dropped as well.

Grade: D


Steven Wright: (62.1IP, 54K, 15BB, 2.17)

Hope: Translate his impressive peripheral numbers (~1K/IP, 3:1 K:BB) into success and advance to Akron quickly

Reality: Wright’s done just that, aided by a miniscule .195 BAA, and should be a candidate for an Akron promotion soon.

Grade: A


Hector Rondon: (58.2IP, 61K, 17BB, 4.14)

Hope: Hold his own at Kinston and carry forward his Lake County stats at the young age of 20.

Reality: By just about any metric other than Ws and Ls, Hector’s done that.  He’s upped his K-rate to over 1/IP and has nearly a 4:1 K:BB ratio.  He has allowed a lot of hits, but things look very bright for the young Venezuelan.

Grade: A


Jeanmar Gomez: (54.2IP, 50K, 21BB, 5.43)

Hope: Like Rondon, hold his own at Kinston (but as a 19-year old)

Reality: Also Like Rondon, Gomez has been the victim of a lot of hits (61).  He’s also walked a few more and, more importantly, been more prone to the HR (8).  If he can cut down the latter, his numbers should improve.  And he’ll still be 19.

Grade: B-


Kinston Relievers: (Josh Tomlin, Luis Perdomo, Neil Wagner, Matt Meyer, Mike Pontius, Dan Cevette)

Reality: A mixed group of older and younger guys and mixed success and keeping guys off base.  But collectively, they throw a lot of strikes (19 more Ks than IP) and don’t walk a lot of guys.  I have a hard time thinking a couple of decent relievers won’t come out of this bunch.

Grade: B




Expectations for most of these guys are pretty low.  Many of these guys are getting their first full-season action.  So we’ll just focus on grades of the interesting guys performance so far.


Chris Nash: (.257/.321/.392)

Reality: Terrible April (.624, 4.5:1 K:BB), better May (.834, 1.5:1 K:BB)

Grade: C


Karexon Sanchez: (.228/.299/.335)

Reality: Great April (.856), terrible May (.462)

Grade: C-


Kelvin De La Cruz: (57.2IP, 52K, 28BB, 1.40)

Reality: It’d be nice to see his walks come down, but you can’t argue with 39 hits allowed and only one HR allowed

Grade: A-


Ryan Morris: (58.2IP, 41K, 21BB, 2.30)

Reality: K-rate, BB-rate, and GB-rate all increased in May. 

Grade: A-


Ryan Miller: (57.1IP, 63K, 27BB, 1.41)

Reality: Nothing to complain about.  Need to see how he does in Kinston now.

Grade: A


Chris Archer: (47IP, 40K, 43BB, 4.40)

Reality: Had a great April by not allowing any hits.  Atrocious walk-rate has brought him back down to earth. Still very young.

Grade: C-


Lake County Relievers (Josh Judy, Jonathan Holt, Kyle Landis, Vinnie Pestano, Dallas Cawiezell):

Reality: I’m not going to comment on these guys individually, low-A relievers really aren’t worth that, but this bunch has been good.  Hopefully one or two of these guys will go forward and turn into something good.

Grade: B+

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior users will need to choose a permanent username, along with a new password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

I already have a Vox Media account!

Verify Vox Media account

Please login to your Vox Media account. This account will be linked to your previously existing Eater account.

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior MT authors will need to choose a new username and password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Let's Go Tribe

You must be a member of Let's Go Tribe to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Let's Go Tribe. You should read them.

Join Let's Go Tribe

You must be a member of Let's Go Tribe to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Let's Go Tribe. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.