This article is the Ruben Amaro, Jr. of Cy Young discussions for 2008. I really am starting to lose my respect for THT if they let stuff like this get posted.
This guy is portending to go "inside the numbers" to show us how much better a season Doc is having. His "inside" the numbers include completely hypothetical statements, five of them beginning with 'if'. Furthermore, even using his "ifs," it only brings Halladay CLOSER to Cliff, not past him.
Real, Actual, Facts/Numbers:
Effective Win-Loss % (WPA Method)
Cliff: 0.813 (1st in AL)
Doc: Not Pictured, but below .691