Rotoauthority finds no relationship between weightloss & performance improvement.
(I was going to make this a FanShot, but it wouldn't let me both quote and link)

After the recent Hafner-lite bar sighting, I thought this article might be of interest. 2008 Indians on the list include Garko, Victor and The Close, all having lost weight and having under performed in 2008.
Hafner's weight loss is due to his recovery from surgery. Whether he will keep it off longer term is unknown. Personally, I think his performance is going to be 98% determined by his health. If he comes back healthy, even if much lighter than his listed 240, he will be a big contributor.
But for those of you thinking that a leaner Hafner might be ideal, this is some evidence to the contrary.
0 recs |
13 comments
Comments
Hafner really can only go sideways or higher. I don’t expect any sort of regression
by Roger Dorn on
Jan 5, 2009 3:48 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
Not to pour on too much haterade, but if his shoulder is still screwed AND he’s smaller AND he’s less comfortable with his swing, he could definitely do worse. Of course, we’d never expect him to play under those conditions, but the pressure to see results might coerce Wedge into playing him sooner than he should (even if subconsciously).
But, as we’ve discussed, we can really only speculate on Hafner until we start to see some play out of him.
by danvail on
Jan 6, 2009 10:21 AM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Remember the good ol days when we were excited about Vic looking trim last ST? Man we must’ve been high as kites last spring.
by supermarioelia on
Jan 5, 2009 6:09 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
Victor injured his hamstring on Opening Day and played with an injured elbow for most of the season. His performance had nothing to do with weight loss, unless somehow losing weight makes your hamstring weaker.
by Ryan on
Jan 6, 2009 12:50 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
This is far from a “correlation.” If it’s a correlation, what is it? What’s the correlation coefficient?
This purely anecdotal, and that’s all. There are lots of reasons why a player might lose weight. It could be a guy who’s been sick or injured. It could be a guy who’s already “lost it” and think (wrongly) that this will help. It could be a guy whom it will actually help with his range and agility on defense.
I see no real correlation whatsoever here, but the original article didn’t claim one. It’s just reporting on the usual memes and mythmaking of these kinds of spring training reports.
by Jay on
Jan 6, 2009 1:42 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
Imprecise wording in my headline.
“Rotoauthority finds no relationship between weightloss & performance improvement” would have been more accurate.
by KevinV on
Jan 6, 2009 2:07 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
I don’t think I’d call it anecdotal, just statistically meaningless. It would take a LOT more data and a much more nuanced set of categorizations to be able to find any sort remotely predictive trends for a specific set of circumstances.
Long story short, I think what the author was trying to demonstrate was that there is specific evidence contrary to the “cliche” that intentionally trimming weight or intentionally bulking up leads to performance improvement.
Looking at what we can take away from this, I’d point out that many here (I believe) correctly pointed out the public relationsiness (new word!) of the Hafner losing weight story. That story attempted to prey on the idea that this article disputes, that if a player is intentionally changing his body weight then it’s a good thing. This article does a passable job of, given one year of data, demonstrating that no such trend is evident.
This article also references a statistically sound piece that correlates body mass to power by age group. That, too, speaks to our situation with Hafner. He’s not as big, expect even less power. It’s an obvious conclusion, but it’s part of shaping expectations for 2009.
by danvail on
Jan 6, 2009 3:32 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Tim Dierkes runs bot RotoAuthority and MLBTradeRumors.
Steel Nick
by nickjs21 on
Jan 6, 2009 3:11 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
Are they run out of two separate Mom’s basements, or just the one?
by jhon on
Jan 6, 2009 3:32 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
I think they’re actually dads’ basements.

by Logodaedalus on
Jan 6, 2009 3:49 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
I have to say, Tim’s running list of Spring Training cliches is a pretty great and totally original piece of content.
by Jay on
Jan 6, 2009 3:52 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs















