Frankly, I worry that Victor’s knee will turn out worse than day-to-day. That was gruesome.

But yeah, if you think about it, Shoppach will replace Victor, and Giminez will replace Shoppach.

Gimenez started off the season with a pretty wretched 0-fer. His May line is .289/.359/.542 – which is much more consistent with what he has done the past two seasons

If Victor can play in a couple of days, then Gimenez will go down, and LaPorta will come up again. If Victor goes on the DL, then LaPorta will probably replace him.

They can recall LaPorta now that there’s an injury.

This really isn’t that hard to comprehend. Prior to the move, they had one able catcher on the MLB roster. Sure, Garko could catch in an emergency, but as of right now, they only had one player who could catch.

Also, with only three bench players, Gimenez adds versatility by being able to play the corner infield and outfield positions.

I believe so

Think so, the sprained ankle didn’t send him to the DL and thats what ended his streak.

reply button

this seems about right.

As I said in one of the game recaps recently – the Indians need to stay within shouting distance in the AL Central until after the All-Star break and they need to do so with the parts already in place. With the possible exception of a DeRosa trade, the Indians aren’t in a position to acquire anyone to help. These injuries don’t change that, they just make it all that much harder. Also, by staying within shouting distance, I don’t just mean games back in the standing but also place in the division. The Indians might, amazingly, only be 7.5 games out of first, but they are still in last place. Which means not only do they have to play very well, but all four of the teams ahead of them have to play worse. Best case scenario for the next three weeks is we stay right around 7 games back but somehow leapfrog one or two of the teams ahead of us.

The real problem is still the pitching and the problems there are not primarily the result of injuries. I guess you could point to Westbrook being out, losing Lewis and Miller right away, and then having Reyes, Smith and Laffey go down. But, Westbrook they knew about and Miller and Reyes were ticking bombs. So, no, Shapiro shouldn’t get a free pass. He hasn’t assembled a strong pitching staff this year and he deserves criticism for that (and he’s more or less taken the blame for it, to his credit).

They didn’t learn from Victor last year, which is just plain too bad.

I don’t buy this idea that Grady was too much of a he-man to go on the DL, and that they eventually had to restrain him and drag him off the field under sedation. No pro team is going to allow a player to play if they feel he is impaired or risks further damage. It’s not likely that Sizemore tells Soloff and Shapiro when he’s going to play.

Today Wedge compared Grady’s elbow to Victor’s last year. Remember how that started? No mention of Victor’s elbow, just a hamstring (or groin) injury. Then they start to talk about mild discomfort, then a public acknowledgment of the injury (while still concealing the extent of the damage). Then, after the surgery, there’s talk of all the loose bone fragments in his elbow, and boy, he must be pretty tough to play with his elbow shot all to hell. I think there’s a possibility Grady has a serious elbow problem, one that’s not going to go away after two weeks in a spa. Maybe the team is trying to see if they can work through the injury and avoid surgery that would lose him for the year.

The Indians have had a terrible record of reporting injuries. I know people here believe there is strategic value in concealing or obscuring injuries, that somehow this will lull the Tigers into keeping Dontrelle in their starting rotation or something. But this cloak-and-dagger stuff is more for marketing purposes.

Teams know Sizemore is hurt. Scouts talk about it. The Indians traditionally downplay every injury. “Day to day,” “he’ll be back in 15 days.” Scott Lewis has been out for, what, 45 games? If Laffey’s oblique injury is like others’ he won’t be back for a long time (a couple months?). And Joe Smith has been gone a while. And despite the team’s best efforts to spin Hafner’s injury, he’s been out for quite some time. Don’t expect Betancourt back anytime soon, and don’t be surprised if Grady doesn’t return for a long time. Victor may also miss real time. The Indians’ “minor” injuries rarely return when initially expected.

I think this is something to keep the fans interested.