With 12 players you absolutely have to do both leagues. I don’t want to be in a situation where I am worried if Felix Pie or Scott Podsednik is going to be getting playing time for that week. That’s no fun.

 I like H2H better than Rotisserie as it keeps people interested all the way through the season. Often with rotisserie, by the all-star break, the guys in the bottom of the standings will quit trying.

Let’s see… preferences…

Both leagues for sure.
Rotisserie is all I’ve ever done, so that.

My, their website is a mess.

Yeah, I’m agreeing with both leagues because of the number of teams.

I’ve played Rotisserie and Head to Head before. The thing I don’t like about Rotisserie is that you can literally be out of the race 1/3 of the way through the season and it makes participating tough to muster in the 2nd half for the lower ranking of teams. I like Head to Head because it seems there is more initiative to pay attention each week and more initiative to pay attention longer. Thoughts?

Whoops, I totally missed this.

What are the Team Names? As a spectator, I demand awesome team names.

My buddy James is in a NASCAR fantasy league (Georgia… don’t ask.) His team name was “The InJimidator”

Fine with full MLB pool.

Prefer H2H, but OK with roto.

Keepers? Standard Draft? Auction?

Re: scoring – I’m fine with modified 5X5 (replace BA with OBP) but also open to expansion. I’ve played leagues with many more categories.

Hate, hate, hate, hate points leagues. Hate em.

Never done H2H before, but I’m down. Both leagues is fine.

Categories, I’d do a modified 5×5 but I’d also replace steals with net steals (if this is even possible), and maybe add walks for pitchers instead of something. But it’s not that big a deal for me.

I generally prefer H2H — it keeps everybody in it.

Aside for not wanting BA and not counting Ks against batters, I’m good.

Spider and MW, It’d probably be nicer if you guys stopped using the subject line :)

And, if I stopped using emoticons.

I prefer roto but i’ll go with the flow. Mixed league makes sense. Whatever kind of draft is fine. I’m a little skeptical about keepers, but mostly because I’ve never done it. I’m going to win.

OK guys, Head-to-Head seems like it’s winning.

We have some options in the scoring system. They are:

1) Most Points is a Win. In other words, add up all the points, and whoever has the most that week is the winner.

2) Most Categories is a Win. Whoever wins the most categories is the winner.

3) Each Category is a Win. So if you win all your categories for the week, you’d be 5-0 and your opponent would be 0-5

I guess I’m partial to either 2) or 3). With 2) it’s a winner-take-all game, and with 3) you can still eke out some points even if your opponent was better overall.

3

3 is the standard H2H. I’ll stick with that.

Instead of starting an unnecessary thread on it, i’ll ask here:

does anyone use a sabermetric fantasy projection system, other than BP’s Player Forecast Manager? I’m in a deep, 8-team AL-only league and have used BP’s platform the past 2 years with relative success, but this year I know for certain that 2 other team owners will be using it, so its marginal benefit is decreasing.

THT has a product, but it doesn’t offer player auction values based on customized league parameters like BP’s does. CHONE has nothing at all.

Any suggestions? feel free to email me at my sbn user name @yahoo.com