Sayonara Trot?
Is it time?
I used to love Trot as a player and in a previous life, he was a good customer of mine. I think, however, that it is time to cut him loose. All he brings is OBP, pie throwing and that ubiquitous grit. His power is totally gone, he can't run anymore and his D has slipped. As long as he was hitting .280, he was at least able to maintain the illusion of production. I find myself rooting for him to keep slumping. This would rip the veneer off of his hollow value so that the FO would be left with no choice. Choo is not a savior but I prefer his "tweener" package of range, arm, speed, some OBP and occasional pop. It was bad enough when Wedge was leaving Trot in to flail against LHP but against RHP, his OPS is still only .706 with a sub .400 slg(!) What does he bring to the table? Is it time?
76 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
by mkwng @ Let's Go Tribe! on Jun 14, 2007 11:39 AM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
SSS
SSS
Look, if you want to complain about the signing, I can understand that. But cutting a guy that we're paying a substantial amount in relation to our payroll isn't helpful. Shapiro made this investment and isn't going to back off of it because of a hundred bad ABs.
Besides, there aren't really better options. Ben Francisco is taking on a vague folkhero status around here at times but he's still a 25 year old only OPSing .893 in Buffalo and that's with a .338 BA. If he were to play a whole ML season at his current pace he'd be lucky to hit 15 homeruns.
Choo is hurt. And before he was hurt he hadn't lit the world on fire.
Franky is already up and there's no reason to cut Trot to get him time. You can just give him time and sit Trot down.
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Should we cut him? No, probably not. Keep him around for pies and grit jokes. But he's a bad player now.
Erstad 2007 - .264/.311/.341
Nixon 2007 - .246/.330/.341
by mkwng @ Let's Go Tribe! on Jun 14, 2007 1:24 PM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Nixon 2007 - .246/.330/.341
/shudders
by Turkmenbashi on Jun 14, 2007 4:22 PM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Everyone else, the Erstad comparison points up that Nixon is showing a little more isolated power and almost double the walk rate. Let's also not forget that he's coming back from an injury.
I expect Trot's numbers to improve as the year goes on. Not that I would put money on it, but July tends to be his best month. Maybe we can sell high at the deadline?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Shapiro paid him for reasons he felt strongly about.
Shapiro doesn't seem the type to let 3 months change his mind about any substantial investment.
Shapiro can keep him on the team, not give up on the investment that he believed in, without hurting the team in anyway. Trot can simply play less and try to work through this.
Thus, Shapiro is not cutting Trot and, frankly, there's no point to doing so. Unless you really believe Genrealissimo is a .380 singles hitter.
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
The contextual difference:
- Quality approach
- Leadership, respect and accountability
- Quality of alternatives
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Pre-2007
http://www.minorleaguesplits.com/pl/450/450204.html
by stuart dean on Jun 14, 2007 11:09 AM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
This from a guy who is certainly not a member of Frank's Fan Club.
I just don't see them cutting Trot loose. Maybe it's an issue with his back that needs rest/trip to the DL.
by The DiaTriber on Jun 14, 2007 12:11 PM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
by stuart dean on Jun 14, 2007 12:34 PM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
2003 .578 (slg)
2004 .510
2005 .446
2006 .394
2007 .341
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
I still think they look to aquire a back end bullpen arm first, but aquiring a regular corner outfielder the quality of Dunn because he should be available (Cincy is going nowhere) will be considered.
Heard a rumor that Colorado might be willing to part with Fuentes, then there's Cordero in Was. and either of the Texas guys as well.
Re: Sayonara Trot?
I think Dunn looks a lot better from afar. He's an extremely frustrating player day to day because of the strikeouts and the defense.
I think you mean Matt Whitney!
Looking more at Fuentes, I can see why you say "dream acquisition" - his K rate is a bit down from the past two years, but that's compensated with a low H rate and a lower BB rate than his past two years, which translates to a much lower WHIP as well (0.82.) And, to top it off, a lower than .200 BAA (.180.)
You mentioned Mulhern and Whitney; I'd even consider throwing Brad Snyder in there if that's what it took to get it done - if the ball travels out of that ballpark like it used to, Snyder could probably hit 30+ HRs, albeit strike out probably close to 200 times, but he might give them either another option to play in CF instead of Taveras or have a very good corner OFer defensively who offers a lot of power.
As for Dunn, I agree with you - I'm not fond of his K rate and his tendency to always pull the ball; that's why I think many consider Dunn to have not quite lived up to his potential when he was coming up through the Minors because he's become a one-dimensional player. In the Minors, he actually hit for a high BA (.300+) and I think he played solid to good defense at one time as well, but not anymore.
No, he'd probably cost too much in terms of talent we'd have to give up for him, and he's a FA after this year, is he not? No, if we'd go after an OFer, I'd rather get someone who is young and would be here for the long-term like Toronto OF Alex Rios, a guy who has developing power, good BA, plays good to great defense with a strong arm - I'd rather the Indians do that than go after a one-dimensional guy like Dunn.
Just my 2 cents. :-)
Re: I think you mean Matt Whitney!
I figured you were kidding (that price seemed
One thing I meant to ask, how long before Fuentes is up for arbitration and free agency? I'd be curious about that before offering a "real" package to the Rockies for him.
Re: Sayonara Trot?
What's particularly interesting (to me at least) is that the Cavs really started playing better when Snow got less playing time - and this was made possible partly by how he handled the demotion - in favor of some of the younger guys.
Shapiro and Ferry have always shared opinions on these matters. I'd love to see Shapiro follow Ferry's lead on this one.
Re: Sayonara Trot?
/rimshot
by Turkmenbashi on Jun 14, 2007 4:20 PM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
are you actually turkish? my mother is turkish and my research is in turkey.
Re: Sayonara Trot?
by homelytourist on Jun 14, 2007 4:44 PM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Well researched, man! I'd shake your hand if I met you. Curious, but did you actually know that or did you look it up?
Anyway, homelytourist is right. I'm not Turkish, but I study post-Soviet Central Asia. Turkmenbashi was a crazy and ecclectic dictator with an insane cult of personality. he's one of those people that makes you pray for the people of his country but you can't help but laugh at the insane things he does. For instance, he named the month of January after himself, and built a golden statue of himself in Ashgabat (capital of Turkmenistan) that rotates to face the sun.
by Turkmenbashi on Jun 14, 2007 6:31 PM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
by Turkmenbashi on Jun 14, 2007 7:56 PM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
by homelytourist on Jun 14, 2007 10:04 PM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
by Turkmenbashi on Jun 15, 2007 12:31 AM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Everybody over there is touting Kazakhstan as the next Saudi Arabia. I'll email you some pictures if you want.
Re: Sayonara Trot?
by Turkmenbashi on Jun 15, 2007 2:18 PM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
And, thanks, Turkmenbashi, for the info. Good luck in your field!
Re: Sayonara Trot?
by Turkmenbashi on Jun 14, 2007 7:57 PM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
by Turkmenbashi on Jun 15, 2007 12:32 AM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
by Turkmenbashi on Jun 15, 2007 1:43 AM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
by Turkmenbashi on Jun 15, 2007 1:51 AM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
I liked it, I just didn't "love it as much as [you] did."
Re: Sayonara Trot?
by Fiddlesticks on Jun 15, 2007 12:21 PM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
by Turkmenbashi on Jun 15, 2007 2:14 PM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
I'm eager to do something crazy like move to Uzbekistan or whatever. Sounds like you've had some rad experiences.
by homelytourist on Jun 14, 2007 9:00 PM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
In all seriousness, though, Russia/Central Asia are going to be huge in the next 15-20 years; I see that area as the new geopolitical battleground in a new "Cold War" (or even "hot war?") with China.
by Turkmenbashi on Jun 15, 2007 12:34 AM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
by Turkmenbashi on Jun 15, 2007 2:19 PM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Not so shocking. Didn't we offer these things to Thome in our contract negotiations?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
by Turkmenbashi on Jun 15, 2007 2:15 PM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Guys like he and Delucci, Roberto Hernandez were safe acquisitions due to their experience and their price tags. Anything beneficial we got out of them would be an exciting bonus. I'm waiting for most of these guys to play their way out of the lineup. Meanwhile the Franciscos and Gutierrez's are getting primed for the big time, or the determination if they can handle the big time, day in and out.
by BoDiaz1974 on Jun 14, 2007 3:27 PM EDT reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
Re: Sayonara Trot?
by Turkmenbashi on Jun 15, 2007 2:15 PM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
by fleerdon on Jun 15, 2007 2:51 PM EDT up reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
by homelytourist on Jun 15, 2007 2:52 PM EDT reply actions
Re: Sayonara Trot?
by Turkmenbashi on Jun 15, 2007 3:03 PM EDT up reply actions

by 
















